Williamsburg in New York

5 places for Williamsburg in New York, picked by creators — with what they said.

Maison Premiere — TOPJAW
Praised the tableside martini — an homage to 1940s hotel bars — the huge daily-changing oyster menu, and finishing the night in the backyard garden.
Heads up: Classic-leaning enough that a margarita only made the main menu for the first time in 13 years.
The Penny Hotel Williamsburg — TOPJAW
Called it cool, convenient, reasonably priced, with a fantastic rooftop terrace.
Heads up: The rooftop bar is closed on Mondays.
Best Pizza — TOPJAW
Praised for making their own mozzarella to control salt and moisture, and for baking unusually large pies for a slice shop in a wood-fired oven.
Peter Luger Steak House — Jon Barr
The lunch burger special made with prime chuck is truly excellent — he prefers it to the steak — and the gruff but funny waiters give it an old-school, throwback feel.
Heads up: Expect a 15-30 minute wait regardless of reservation time, service is brusque, and prices are high.
elNico Rooftop — TOPJAW
Praised for margaritas with real character unlike any tried before, including the Verd-rita made with fresh avocado.
Heads up: The margaritas are said to be quite strong.